Tuesday, May 10, 2011

Guilty by Billboard

Bahrain, like all countries of the Arab world, is no stranger to political billboards, especially those meant to demonstrate or evoke loyalty to the ruling troika of the king, prime minister, and crown prince. In the barber shop, at a restaurant, in someone's office, at the mall--everywhere one finds the familiar display of faces smiling beneficently. Here's a nice one of the prime minister, for example, close to the al-Fatih Mosque:


Thus it is perhaps no surprise that this institution of the political billboard is expanding its reach from the general "remember who your leader is" sort of purpose into the more specific realm of public opinion. In this case, while the mass trial of Bahrain's 21 opposition figures has not even started yet in full, their guilt is already being proclaimed via massive billboards spread across the island.

To be sure, even this is nothing new. When many of the same individuals were arrested and tried in late 2010, a heavy billboard and media campaign railed against this supposed "terrorist group," urging Bahrain's leaders to punish its leaders with a heavy hand for fomenting sectarian division, ruining the country, and whatever else it is that non-terrorist terrorist organizations do. (Update: for some examples of these, see reader submissions #2 and #3 below.)

At that time, the following "terrorist organization" flow-chart was published in the Sept. 16, 2010, issue of the most hard-line pro-government newspaper, Al-Watan, said to be owned or at least supervised by the royal court.


In case you cannot follow the logic of the diagram here, it goes something like this: there is a terrorist network led by Hasan al-Musheimi', Sh. Muhammad al-Miqdad (both of which are among the 21 now on trial again), as well as this ghostly figure "Others?" with a question mark to get you thinking. Next we have the second-tier members of the terrorist network: two guys named Sami Mirza and Ahmad 'Abdallah along with more "Others?" This shadowy group that may or may not consist of only 4 people then engages in various terrorist activities, including but not limited to lighting cars on fire, using some sort of a burning stop-watch, lighting houses on fire, and slicking the sidewalk down with ice thereby making people trip and fall. (This is the last and more illustrative level of the flow-chart.)

Having saved this newspaper clipping for all these months knowing that it would come in handy at some point, imagine my surprise when I see a near-replica of it in billboard form on the ground now in Bahrain. Sure, there are a few more names, and the text is different, but the idea and the message is recognizably the same. It even uses the same "Others?" technique that proved so illustrative in the Al-Watan flow-chart above. Thus it is difficult to escape the fact that either a) the maker of the billboard saw the article in Al-Watan and copied it, or b) the maker of the billboard is more closely related to the Al-Watan article.

Located in Muharraq, the billboard of top opposition leaders al-Mushaimi', 'Abd al-Wahhab Hussain, al-Miqdad, Ebrahim Sharif, and al-Singace reads at the top, "Disease must be excised from the body of the nation." And at bottom: "We won't keep quiet after today about any mistakes or excesses by those who abuse Bahrain and its people." Nice.


Another, below, with the same graphics but different text, reads, "You all are responsible for what happened to our secure Bahrain." (Sorry for the blurry image. Presumably whoever took the photo wanted to do so quickly before he could be arrested for spying.)


Finally, we have another billboard that purports to be not from the government but a request TO the government, from the Al-Hidd youth: "We request of the government... the greatest punishment: NO PARDON for the heads of fitna and the misguided elements." The noose is a subtle touch.


The main lesson?: Muharraq likes its political billboards.

For more billboard madness, see this page from 2004, which among other things demonstrates that this is a tried and true technique. (Here is another, longer version.) And if you have any Bahrain billboard favorites of your own, feel free to post them in the comments section and I will add them to the mix.

Unrelated Update: the Washington Post is finally getting with the program, running an editorial today titled "Applying pressure on Bahrain." Funny that it rejected an almost identical piece I sent more than a month and a half ago. In any case, the punchline is surprisingly forceful:
"The best way to protect American interests is to tell both regimes [Saudi and Bahrain] that a continued security relationship with the United States depends on an end to policies of sectarian repression and on the implementation of moderate reforms. Meanwhile, it’s time to start looking for a new home for the 5th Fleet."
Billboards from Readers:

1.) Sign from al-Busaiteen invoking the sayings of 'Adal Flaifel and calling for the establishment of a "popular army" named Hamad's Popular Army; and, given the quotation below it--"For life, O Brothers and Sisters, gets its value from death"--is calling for martyrdom.


From Wikipedia: Colonel Adel Jassim Flaifel ... is a former colonel in the State Security and Intelligence Service of Bahrain. He is accused of committing, or overseeing, acts of physical and psychological torture on Bahraini citizens from 1980s until 1997. He was released from his duties in December 2002 due to protests and pressures from human rights organizations worldwide.

2.) From August 2010 (and related to the "terrorist network" image from Al-Watan).


"Justice and Law is a sword upon the heads of fitna and terrorism and those who play around with the security of the nation."

3.) More from the same time period, decrying the "terrorism" of tire-burning. "Quick! Evacuate the building! We've received reports that a burning tire is headed this way!"

11 comments:

  1. A new billboard, can't confirm where it was taken but it's signed as Busaiteen

    It lists some important quotes of Adel Falifel, the first is to orgnize civil militia in the name of "Hamad defense army"

    http://i54.tinypic.com/np126r.jpg

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is also good to note that the blurred image used in the recent billboard representing "others" is actually a blurred image of Sayed Hadi al-Modarresi. If you look closely, you'll see it... Either way, it is provoking more sectarianism as even if you cannot recognize al-Modarresi from it, you can make out an image of a bearded man with a black turban.

    ReplyDelete
  3. And some billboards from last August

    http://www.alwasatnews.com/2912/news/read/471633/1.html

    http://img714.imageshack.us/img714/6484/lafetat.png

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just to wanted to say that I enjoy reading your posts. Please continue your nice work. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Actually I spent time looking for the one from al-Wasat. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the link to my old post about billboards. Here is another one on the topic:
    http://chanadbahraini.blogspot.com/2005/01/just-say-no-to-public-bumlicking.html

    Also, you forgot to point out that the blurred out photo behind the the "Others ?" box on the billboards is Iraqi Shia cleric Sayed Hadi al-Modarresi. Al-Modarressi was invited to Bahrain by the then ruler in the 70s to preach religion to offset the political influence of the leftists/nationalists. He was later deported from Bahrain and accused of planning a coup against the Al Khalifa regime.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oops, just noticed that another commenter already pointed out the point about al-Modarresi

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yes I guess it is an upgrade from the blacked-out cartoon face from Al-Watan. Thanks for pointing it out and the for the new link.

    ReplyDelete
  9. r u ppl blind, the blurred image is of an old man with a gray beard. plz get ur facts straight, in this case ur vision, be4 u start accusing ppl

    ReplyDelete
  10. forever_zo..seems you are the only ignorant here that needs to get the facts straight ! google the name and you will find an identical picture of al modaresi !!

    ReplyDelete